Player Prop Results for October 17, 2026: Graded Wins and Losses

We went 262-397 on October 17, 2026, across 659 graded player props. That’s a losing day, and we’re stating it plainly: 262 wins, 397 losses.

By the Numbers

• NHL: 209-287
• WNBA: 37-80
• MLB: 16-30

Biggest Wins

• Calum Ritchie (NHL) — Shots On Goal Under: WIN, actual 0.0. Our analysis leaned under on his shot volume, and he finished without a shot, clearing the line comfortably.
• Allisha Gray (WNBA) — Threes Under 1.50: WIN, actual 1.0. LineCrush’s models projected limited perimeter volume, and she ended on one made three, landing the under.
• Matthew Tkachuk (NHL) — Assists Over: WIN, actual 3.0. A standout over. He delivered three helpers, well past the threshold.
• Tyson Foerster (NHL) — Points Under 0.50: WIN, actual 0.0. We needed a scoreless result for the under to cash, and Foerster finished without a point.
• Alex Laferriere (NHL) — Points Over: WIN, actual 1.0. One point was enough, and he got there to push the over through.

Where We Missed

• Neal Pionk (NHL) — Points Over 0.50: LOSS, actual 0.0. We needed a point and didn’t get it; he finished scoreless.
• Seth Jones (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over 1.50: LOSS, actual 1.0. The over required at least two; he ended with one, short of the mark.
• Connor Bedard (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over: LOSS, actual 2.0. Our pick needed more volume than two shots; it didn’t materialize.
• Wyatt Johnston (NHL) — Shots On Goal Under: LOSS, actual 5.0. The under was not close here; Johnston put five on net, clearly over.
• Nick Martinez (MLB) — Pitcher Strikeouts Under 2.50: LOSS, actual 3.0. We played the under, but he reached three strikeouts, clearing the line.

Every pick is graded publicly on LineCrush, win or lose. You can see the full slate of 659 graded props from October 17, 2026—along with each result exactly as it happened—on our site. Our analysis reflects what players and coaches are saying, how they’re feeling, the stats, and the odds, and we hold ourselves accountable by posting the record as it stands.

Want the full breakdown? See today's picks and analysis at linecrush.com/picks.