Player Prop Results for October 13, 2026: Graded Wins and Losses

We went 338-381 on October 13, 2026 — 719 graded player props, with more losses than wins. That’s the full, unvarnished record for the day. Our analysis graded every pick and publishes each result, and this recap lays out the sport-by-sport split and the most notable highs and lows from yesterday.

By the Numbers

• NHL: 304-331
• MLB: 25-31
• NBA: 9-19

Biggest Wins

• Freddy Peralta (MLB) — Pitcher Earned Runs Under: WIN, actual 0.0. LineCrush’s models leaned to the under on Peralta’s run prevention, and he delivered a clean sheet. Any under on earned runs is binary and unforgiving; a zero is exactly what you want, and he gave it.
• Matthew Schaefer (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over: WIN, actual 4.0. We needed volume, and Schaefer cleared it with four shots on target, putting this one away without sweating a hook.
• Jack Roslovic (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over: WIN, actual 2.0. The over cashed with two on goal, a straightforward clearance that aligned with our read on his usage.
• Cole Caufield (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over: WIN, actual 5.0. Caufield’s trigger was active; five SOG comfortably pushed this over across the line and matched our expectation for shot aggression.
• Fraser Minten (NHL) — Points Over: WIN, actual 2.0. Points props can hinge on linemates and opportunity; Minten turned those chances into two points, clearing the over decisively.

Where We Missed

• Chandler Simpson (MLB) — Batter Stolen Bases Over: LOSS, actual 0.0. We projected pressure on the bases; it didn’t materialize. Zero steals is a clean miss on an aggressive over stance.
• Brandin Podziemski (NBA) — Points Assists Over 24.50: LOSS, actual 19.0. We were on the combined production over; he finished at 19.0, well short of 24.50, and this never threatened late.
• Evan Bouchard (NHL) — Shots On Goal Over 2.50: LOSS, actual 1.0. We needed volume from the blue line and didn’t get it. One shot on goal left this comfortably under the 2.50 number.
• Gage Goncalves (NHL) — Points Over 0.50: LOSS, actual 0.0. A simple yes/no threshold on a point; he didn’t register one, and the over did not cash.
• Philip Broberg (NHL) — Points Over: LOSS, actual 0.0. We took the over on points; he finished without one, and this was a clear miss.

What this means for the slate: the NHL carried most of the volume at 304-331, and while there were standout wins — from Caufield’s shot barrage to Minten’s two-point night — we didn’t convert enough edges across the board to end up positive on the day. MLB closed 25-31, highlighted by Freddy Peralta’s zero earned runs, but also marked by a miss on stolen-base aggression with Chandler Simpson at 0.0. NBA went 9-19, and the shortfall showed up in combined-production targets like Brandin Podziemski’s 19.0 against 24.50.

Bottom line: 338-381 is the record. We grade every pick publicly, win or lose, and you can audit yesterday’s props one by one on LineCrush — the same accountability we bring every day.

Want the full breakdown? See today's picks and analysis at linecrush.com/picks.