Player Prop Results for September 19, 2026: Graded Wins and Losses

Yesterday’s picks finished 363-406-1 across 770 graded player props on September 19, 2026. That’s a losing day, and we’re stating it plainly: more losses than wins, with one push. LineCrush’s models had mixed results by sport, and we’re laying out the full breakdown below so you can see exactly what hit and what didn’t.

By the Numbers

• MLB: 334-387
• WNBA: 29-19-1

Biggest Wins

• Jackson Jobe (MLB) — Pitcher Strikeouts Over 4.50: WIN, actual 9.0. Our analysis projected a path to upside on the K ladder, and Jobe cleared the number decisively, finishing five strikeouts above the line.
• Christian Scott (MLB) — Pitcher Strikeouts Over 5.50: WIN, actual 7.0. Another strikeout Over that got home with room to spare, landing a clean one-and-a-half above the posted line.
• Fernando Tatis Jr. (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Over 1.50: WIN, actual 4.0. Tatis delivered solid total bases production, more than doubling the requirement and validating the Over.
• Freddy Peralta (MLB) — Pitcher Earned Runs Under: WIN, actual 1.0. The Under cashed with a one-earned-run outing, a controlled performance that stayed comfortably beneath the mark.
• Steven Kwan (MLB) — Batter Singles Over: WIN, actual 2.0. Kwan did exactly what this market asks for—stack singles—and he hit two to clear the Over.

Where We Missed

• Oneil Cruz (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Under: LOSS, actual 2.0. We were on the Under, but Cruz reached two total bases, which was enough to beat the position we took.
• Kyle Tucker (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Over 1.50: LOSS, actual 1.0. Tucker came up short at one total base, missing the Over by a half-base.
• Freddie Freeman (MLB) — Batter Hits Over: LOSS, actual 0.0. This one didn’t get off the ground—no hits recorded, so the Over never had a chance.
• Elly De La Cruz (MLB) — Batter Stolen Bases Over: LOSS, actual 0.0. We needed activity on the basepaths; it didn’t happen, and the Over lost with zero steals.
• Jackson Jobe (MLB) — Pitcher Outs Under: LOSS, actual 18.0. Separate from the strikeout win, we also backed the Outs Under, and it missed—Jobe reached 18 outs, pushing past the Under call.

What this means for the day: MLB volume drove the overall result, and despite some strong hits—especially on pitcher strikeout Overs and selective batter Overs—we had more red than green. WNBA finished positive at 29-19-1, but it wasn’t enough to offset the MLB deficit. That’s the unvarnished picture of September 19, 2026.

A few takeaways from our side:

• Strikeout Overs on Jobe and Scott were clear wins, aligning with how our analysis identified punchout upside.
• Total bases markets were a split decision—Tatis cleared comfortably, while Tucker and Cruz (on opposite sides) went the other way against our positions.
• Binary stat props like hits and steals can swing hard; both Freddie Freeman (hits Over) and Elly De La Cruz (stolen bases Over) landed on zero, and those are losses we own.

Every pick we make is graded publicly on LineCrush, win or lose, and yesterday’s 363-406-1 is on the board with each result. If you tailed, you can audit every slip against the posted grades. We’ll keep publishing the full ledger daily so you can track our performance in real time.

Want the full breakdown? See today's picks and analysis at linecrush.com/picks.