Player Prop Results for September 18, 2026: Graded Wins and Losses

September 18, 2026 recap: 282-304 across 586 graded player props. That’s 282 wins and 304 losses, plainly. LineCrush’s models graded every pick, and the slate finished in the red on volume, even with several high-quality hits.

Our analysis logged two sports on the day, with MLB shouldering most of the action and WNBA delivering a smaller but positive contribution.

By the Numbers

• MLB: 251-280
• WNBA: 31-24

Biggest Wins

• Olivia Miles (WNBA) — Points Over 19.50: WIN, actual 20.0
  LineCrush’s models cleared this by the thinnest margin possible. The over hit at 20.0, a half-point sweat that landed on the right side.

• Caitlin Clark (WNBA) — Assists Over 8.50: WIN, actual 14.0
  This one wasn’t close. The over cashed with room to spare as Clark dished 14.0, beating the line by 5.5.

• Nick Pivetta (MLB) — Pitcher Walks Under: WIN, actual 1.0
  A clean under on free passes. Holding at 1.0 walk kept the wager safely under the unspecified line and in the win column.

• Julio Rodriguez (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Under: WIN, actual 0.0
  Zero total bases is as decisive as it gets. This under never came under threat.

• Tyler Mahle (MLB) — Pitcher Outs Over 17.50: WIN, actual 18.0
  Mahle reached 18.0 outs, clearing the 17.50 over by a single out. A tight but successful read from our analysis.

Where We Missed

• Olivia Miles (WNBA) — Points Under 19.50: LOSS, actual 20.0
  The under lost by 0.5. The same thin margin that made the over a winner made this an outright loss.

• Paul Skenes (MLB) — Pitcher Strikeouts Under 5.50: LOSS, actual 7.0
  This was not close. With 7.0 strikeouts, the under missed by 1.5 Ks.

• Alex Bregman (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Over 1.50: LOSS, actual 0.0
  The over needed two total bases and got none. That’s a straightforward miss.

• Jo Adell (MLB) — Batter Total Bases Over 1.50: LOSS, actual 1.0
  Landed one base short. At 1.0 total base, the over 1.50 did not get there.

• Oneil Cruz (MLB) — Batter Hits Under 0.50: LOSS, actual 3.0
  This was a clear miss. With 3.0 hits, the under on 0.50 never had a chance.

What it Means

• Overall, the card finished 22 games under .500 at 282-304.
• MLB carried volume and ended 29 games under .500 (251-280).
• WNBA contributed a winning 31-24, highlighted by a razor-thin over on Olivia Miles and a decisive assist over from Caitlin Clark.

Every pick listed above — and all 586 from the day — is graded publicly on LineCrush, win or lose. We publish the full record transparently so you can see exactly how our analysis performed on September 18, 2026, and track it day by day.

Want the full breakdown? See today's picks and analysis at linecrush.com/picks.