Player Prop Results for September 12, 2026: Graded Wins and Losses

Quick answer: On September 12, 2026, LineCrush’s models went 284-335 across 619 graded player props. That’s a losing day, with more misses than hits, all fully graded and posted.

We publish every graded pick — wins and losses — and we’re recapping the results exactly as they happened.

By the Numbers

• MLB: 284-335 (all 619 props)

Biggest Wins

• Sean Newcomb — Pitcher Outs Under: WIN, actual 4.0
  Our analysis called for the Under on Newcomb’s outs, and it wasn’t close. He was pulled early, finishing at 4.0 outs, well below typical starter thresholds, delivering a clean Under.

• Corbin Carroll — Batter Total Bases Under: WIN, actual 0.0
  Carroll was held in check with zero total bases. LineCrush’s models were on the Under, and the blank line made this one straightforward.

• Bryan Woo — Pitcher Outs Over: WIN, actual 18.0
  Woo got through six full innings (18 outs), validating the Over call. Stamina and efficiency lined up with our projection, and the result matched the read.

• Ian Happ — Batter Total Bases Under: WIN, actual 0.0
  Happ finished with no total bases, landing squarely on the Under as projected by our analysis.

• Miguel Vargas — Batter Total Bases Under 1.50: WIN, actual 1.0
  Vargas ended at 1.0 total base, staying comfortably below the 1.50 threshold. This was a precise number we needed to dodge, and it stayed Under.

Where We Missed

• Teoscar Hernandez — Batter Total Bases Over: LOSS, actual 0.0
  We backed the Over, and it landed dead on zero. No sugarcoating it — that’s a clear miss.

• Paul Skenes — Pitcher Outs Under 15.50: LOSS, actual 21.0
  We played the Under 15.50, and Skenes worked deep, recording 21 outs. This wasn’t close; the Under never had a chance with that workload.

• Anthony Volpe — Batter Total Bases Over 1.50: LOSS, actual 0.0
  We needed at least two total bases; Volpe ended with none. That’s a straight Over miss.

• Adley Rutschman — Batter Total Bases Under 1.50: LOSS, actual 2.0
  We took the Under 1.50, and Rutschman cleared it with 2.0 total bases. The number beat us; this one graded a Loss.

• George Springer — Batter Hits Under 0.50: LOSS, actual 2.0
  We needed zero hits for the Under, but Springer recorded two. That’s a definitive miss against our position.

Closing

Every single pick is graded and posted publicly by LineCrush — win or lose. Yesterday finished 284-335 in MLB (619 props total), and the full ledger is available so you can audit our results anytime.

Want the full breakdown? See today's picks and analysis at linecrush.com/picks.